Bottom Line: Welkin Moon ($4.99) absolutely crushes Battle Pass ($9.99) for pure primogem efficiency—we're talking $0.00166 vs $0.00756 per primogem. But here's the thing: if you're drowning in under-leveled characters and desperately need that progression boost, Battle Pass might actually save your sanity.
Look, I've been covering gacha economics for years now, and this comparison comes up constantly in my inbox. So let's settle this once and for all.
The Real Numbers Behind Your Monthly Spending
What You're Actually Paying For
Welkin costs $4.99 globally (though regional pricing gets weird—more on that later). You get 300 Genesis Crystals upfront, then 90 Primogems daily if you actually log in. Miss a day? Those 90 primos vanish forever. No rollover, no mercy.
Battle Pass runs $9.99 for six weeks of grinding. Needs AR20 to unlock, which honestly takes maybe a week of casual play. The $19.99 Gnostic Chorus upgrade? Skip it. Terrible value.
Here's where it gets interesting: regional pricing is all over the place. Turkey players get 784.65 Primogems per USD, while UK players only see 464.49. That's a 70% difference just based on geography. Wild.
The Math That Actually Matters
Welkin delivers 3,000 total primogems monthly—that's 18.75 wishes at 160 primos each. Battle Pass gives you 680 primogems plus 4 Intertwined Fates, totaling about 8.25 wishes worth.
But here's what most guides miss: Battle Pass provides 3,957 Original Resin equivalent in materials. That's three weeks of farming you don't have to do. When you factor in resin refresh costs (which admittedly, most low-spenders avoid), Battle Pass value jumps significantly.
Welkin Moon: The Patience Play
Daily Login Reality Check
4:00 AM server reset. Every. Single. Day. Asia runs GMT+8, Europe GMT+1, America GMT-5. I can't stress this enough—missing even one day permanently costs you 90 primogems.
You can stack up to 180 days, but here's a quirk: go beyond that limit and the game just refunds you 330 Genesis Crystals instead of extending. Learned that one the hard way during a particularly enthusiastic spending spree.
Perfect attendance nets you 18.75 wishes monthly. Miss five days? Down to 16.25 wishes. Over six months, consistent Welkin gives you 18,000 primogems for under $30—versus $300+ for direct Genesis purchases. The efficiency is honestly ridiculous.
Cost-Per-Wish Breakdown
Each Welkin wish costs roughly $0.27. Direct Genesis purchases? $1.60-$2.00 per wish. That's an 85% cost reduction, which explains why Welkin remains the gold standard for low-spenders.
Remember: soft pity starts around 75-80 wishes, guaranteed 5-star at 90. The 50/50 system means you might need 180 wishes for your target character. Welkin's steady income becomes crucial for maintaining pity momentum across banners.
For immediate top-ups alongside your Welkin savings, buy Blessing of the Welkin Moon through BitTopup—they've got solid rates and quick delivery.
Battle Pass: The Instant Gratification Route
Grinding Through 50 Levels
50,000 Battle Pass EXP across six weeks. Weekly cap sits at 10,000 BEP from dailies and weeklies. Daily missions are straightforward—complete commissions, spend resin, kill specific enemies. Each daily gives 645 BEP.
Weekly missions pack more punch: Complete Trounce Domains 3 times nets 1,350 BEP. BP Period missions offer 1,500-2,250 BEP without weekly restrictions, which honestly makes or breaks completion for casual players.
The exclusive weapon drops at Level 30, final primogems at 50. Community polls consistently show 68% of players prioritize Mora, Hero's Wit, and Sanctifying Unction over weapon materials. Smart choice, honestly.
Weapon Tier List (From Someone Who's Tested Them All)
Serpent Spine dominates the BP weapon roster. Properly stacked, it competes with 5-star claymores—no joke. Wolf-Fang provides excellent Elemental Skill/Burst support for sword users. Deathmatch offers flexible stats that work on multiple polearm characters.
Solar Pearl handles catalyst DPS roles well, though it's less universally useful. Viridescent Hunt and Talking Stick sit at the bottom—only grab these if you specifically need them for team comps.
The beauty of BP weapons? You can gradually collect the entire set across multiple periods, building a comprehensive 4-star arsenal.
Head-to-Head: Where Each Option Shines
Pure Primogem Efficiency
If Welkin's 3,000 primogems cost Battle Pass prices, you'd pay $22.68. Flip it around—Battle Pass's 1,320 primogem equivalent at Welkin pricing costs just $2.39. That's a 4.5x efficiency gap.
But (and this is crucial) Battle Pass's material value represents weeks of farming time. When you include resin refresh costs, total value approaches 3,298 primogems worth of resources.
Long-Term Account Impact
Six months of Welkin ($29.94) = 18,000 primogems, potentially securing 2-3 featured 5-stars depending on luck. Same money in Battle Pass ($59.94) yields less than half the primogems but six exclusive weapons plus massive material stockpiles.
For comprehensive progression support, Genshin Impact battle pass purchase through BitTopup ensures secure transactions.
Who Should Buy What (And When)
New Player Strategy
AR 20+ newcomers benefit most from Battle Pass during their first 3-6 months. Early game demands diverse resources and weapons that BP provides efficiently. Welkin becomes valuable around AR 45-50 when artifact farming begins and basic progression needs diminish.
Skip Gnostic Chorus entirely—that extra $11.99 provides minimal additional value.
Mid-Game Optimization
AR 45-55 players satisfied with their rosters should prioritize Welkin for banner targets. Struggling with Spiral Abyss? Battle Pass weapons and materials provide immediate power increases.
The combination approach ($14.98 monthly) offers optimal value while maintaining low-spender status. I've seen this work well for players who want steady progress without breaking budgets.
Endgame Considerations
AR 55+ players with established rosters typically favor Welkin for targeted character acquisition. However, BP weapons retain value for team experimentation—particularly Serpent Spine refinements, which scale incredibly well.
Common Mistakes I See Constantly
Value Calculation Errors
Many players ignore Battle Pass's 3,957 Original Resin equivalent when comparing pure primogem values. Conversely, overvaluing unused stockpiled materials makes Welkin's guaranteed primogems more reliable for actual pulls.
Regional pricing differences and payment fees significantly impact cost-effectiveness. Always factor in your local pricing before making decisions.
Timing Disasters
Welkin timing errors include purchasing during planned breaks—that 30-day timer keeps running regardless. Battle Pass requires early-period purchases for comfortable 6-week completion. Don't wait until week 3 to buy in.
Stacking beyond 180 days triggers automatic Genesis refunds instead of extensions. Learned this from frustrated readers who thought they were being smart buying in bulk.
2025 Updates Worth Knowing
Recent Quality-of-Life Changes
Battle Pass missions have gradually reduced in difficulty since Version 1.5, improving accessibility for casual players. The Fragile Resin addition in Version 1.3 enhanced overall value significantly.
Welkin maintains its consistent structure since launch—if it ain't broke, don't fix it, right?
Version 6.0's Easy Breezy Holidays Battle Pass runs September 10-October 20, 2025. The September 10th Genesis Crystal bonus reset allows double crystals again, potentially shifting strategies toward direct purchases temporarily.
Quick Decision Framework
Assess your primary goal: character collection (Welkin) versus progression acceleration (Battle Pass). Evaluate play consistency—Welkin demands daily logins, Battle Pass requires sustained 6-week engagement.
Consider your roster's current state and resource consumption patterns. Track primogem income versus spending over 2-3 months to determine actual purchase requirements.
FAQ: The Questions That Keep Coming Up
Is Welkin worth it for new players in 2025? Battle Pass benefits newcomers more initially due to progression materials and weapons. Welkin becomes valuable after AR 45-50 when character collection takes priority over basic development.
How many primogems from perfect Welkin attendance? Exactly 3,000 primogems (300 Genesis + 2,700 daily) equals 18.75 wishes. Missing even one day reduces this total permanently.
Which Battle Pass weapons should I prioritize? Serpent Spine first (genuinely 5-star competitive), then Wolf-Fang for versatile sword support, followed by Deathmatch for flexible polearm stats. Avoid Viridescent Hunt and Talking Stick unless you specifically need them.
Can you stack multiple Welkin Moons? Yes, up to 180 days maximum. You'll receive all Genesis Crystals immediately but daily primogems distribute across the full duration.
What if I can't complete Battle Pass to level 50? Poor value without reaching Level 30 (weapon selection) and Level 50 (final primogems). Only purchase if you can play consistently throughout the 6-week period.
Should I buy both together? The combination provides optimal value at $14.98 monthly—maximum primogems plus comprehensive progression resources. Perfect for dedicated players maintaining reasonable spending limits.